IntroductionDiscinaceae is a family of fungi that includes lorchels, cup fungi, and truffles. Lorchels, also known as false morels, are defined as the stipitate Discinaceae fungi, some of which are toxic due to the production of gyromitrin (e.g., Gyromitra spp.) and others choice edibles (e.g., Maublancomyces gigas, Neogyromitra caroliniana). Significant progress in Discincaeae systematics has been made in recent years. Dirks et al. (2025) used whole-genome analyses to determine evolutionary relationships in the family and revised the taxonomy to include two tribes (tribe Discineae and tribe Gyromitreae), each with five genera (Figure 1). With a focus on DNA barcoding original nomenclatural type specimens, further taxonomic studies have contributed to a refined understanding of particular genera or more narrow species complexes. However, there remain many taxonomic questions and likely undescribed species in the group. This post is not meant to resolve all these issues or summarize all the taxonomic work and various opinions of mycologists over the centuries. Rather, it is meant to capture, organize, and communicate in real-time the expanding number of species-level clades being uncovered with DNA barcoding (currently at 102 species-level clades). Figure 1. Amongst the Discinaceae fungi, identification to genus is usually possible based on pictures of macromorphology alone for lorchels in the genera Gyromitra, Maublancomyces, Neogyromitra, Paragyromitra, Pseudorhizina, and Pseudoverpa (however, Pseudoverpa and Gyromitra can sometimes be difficult to tell apart). The cup fungi typically need microscopic analysis for reliable identification to genus (Discina, Maublancomyces, Neogyromitra, Piscidiscina, and Pseudodiscina). In this endeavor, the study of mature spores is essential, as summarized by Van Vooren (2009a) below (translated from French). The difficulty of recognizing these species in the field is matched only by the patience required to wait, sometimes several weeks, for the spores to mature after harvesting. Indeed, spore ornamentation—an essential characteristic for affirming a determination in these genera—forms late, and it is rare for a harvest of ascomas, even fully developed ones, to show even partial maturity upon immediate examination. It is then necessary to store them for a long time in a humidified box, in the refrigerator, sometimes until partial decomposition, to obtain interpretable spore ornamentation. Another complication arises from the fact that fruiting bodies growing in close proximity can be different species, as observed by Van Vooren and Hentic (2025) in the collection of Discina perlata and Discina spinosospora "a few dozen meters" away from each other, and by David Wasilewski in the collection of Discina sp. 'MI01' and Discina warnei growing potentially on the same log! The list below is a compilation of Discinaceae species, both well characterized ones and ones that are linked by temporary species codes due to uncertain species identity or a likely novel status. As it stands, besides for a few well characterized taxa and even with detailed microscopic analysis, identification to the level of species for many groups is tentative or impossible without DNA sequencing. More well documented collections with DNA barcode data are essential for complete characterization of Discinaceae fungi, which will ultimately facilitate more reliable field identification. Figure 2. Diagnostic TableSpecies ListTribe DiscineaeDiscina (13 species) Discina species are brown cup fungi that largely look the same. Their mature ascospores are ellipsoid to fusoid with a single pointed apiculus on each end, an irregular reticulate surface ornamentation, and one or three guttules (one large central guttule and two small polar guttules). Perhaps someday collections will be identifiable to species and not just genus based on a combination of microscopy, biogeography, and ecology. But for now, the genus is a taxonomic mess. As Discina used to be something of a catchall category for discoid fungi (like Peziza), there are many old names that have no diagnostic information or sequence data. Sequencing these old type specimens, studying their morphology, and designating epitype or neotype specimens when necessary will be crucial. Western North America seems particularly rich in Discina species. It is unknown whether this is a result of sampling bias or if it is indicative of a Discina biodiversity hotspot. Many parts of the world are undersampled. Available Discina species names that cannot yet be confidently assigned to phylogenetic clades include Discina ancilis, Discina intermedia, Discina fluctuans, Discina macrospora, and Discina radiosensilis (Van Vooren and Moreau 2009a, 2009b). With eight unnamed species-level phylogenetic clades listed below and five unassigned names listed above, there are certaintly undescribed Discina species!
Maublancomyces (18 species) Maublancomyces includes the well known and widely consumed giant lorchels like Maublancomyces korfii (Eastern United States), Maublancomyces montanus (Western United States), and Maublancomyces gigas (Europe). It also includes discoid species that are difficult to identify. Macroscopically, they typically have a yellow-brown color that can result in confusion with Piscidiscina leucoxantha. Darker ascocarps can be mistaken for Discina. However, microscopically, the spores are distinct, possessing a blunt or knobbed apiculus rather than acute, pointed apiculi (Discina) or ones with a concave depression (Piscidiscina). Discoid species
Stipitate species
Neogyromitra (6 species) Neogyromitra was the subject of a recent taxonomic study (Miller et al. 2025) and is therefore the most well studied and completely resolved of the Discinaceae genera. Like Maublancomyces, Neogyromitra includes discoid and stipitate (lorchel) species. The stipitate species are readily identifiable based on their distinctive macromorphology. The discoid species require microscopic study for determination. The multiple apiculi on each end of the ascospore are a diagnostic trait. Discoid species
Stipitate species
Piscidiscina (3 species) The genus Piscidiscina is readily identifiable with microscopy. The mature ascospores have a single truncated apiculus on each end with a concave depression. This is the origin of the name Piscidiscina, which means "fish cup" in reference to these fishtail-like apiculi.
Pseudodiscina (2 species) Pseudodiscina is a small genus of discoid fungi known from the Western United States and China. The genus is readily identified via microscopy. Unlike other genera in tribe Discineae, Pseudodiscina species have ellipsoid spores with two guttules and no apiculi. I expect there are undescribed species in this group that will be discovered with increased sampling of discoid Discinaceae species from across the world.
Tribe GyromitreaeGyromitra (8 species) The quintessential lorchel, Gyromitra species have a distinct stipe with a brain-like (cerebriform) hymenophore. They are highly toxic due to the production of gyromitrin, but they are also consumed as a delicacy in many parts of the world after detoxification via boiling. The species are largely indistinguishable from one another, although close study may reveal subtle differences or microscopic characteristics that could be used to separate species. Instead, species are defined based on geography and phylogenetic structure. Given it its long history of study in Europe, Gyromitra is surprisingly undersequenced there, making it difficult to evaluate species ranges across the continent.
Hydnotrya (40 species) Hydnotrya constitutes the only truffle or sequestrate group in the Discinaceae. Due to their subterranean growth, they are not collected or documented as frequently as most of the other genera. However, the available sequence data indicate that there are many undescribed species, and there are likely many more clades that have not yet been discovered. Available species names that are not linked to species-level phylogenetic clades include H. confusa, H. inordinata, H. subnix, H. variiformis, and H. yukonensis.
Paragyromitra (8 species) Paragyromitra species produce saddle-shaped musrooms. They are macroscopically and microscopically similar to Gyromitra species but are more closely related to the truffles in genus Hydnotrya than they are to Gyromitra, necessitating their own genus. While Paragyromitra occurs in temperate and even subtropical regions across the world, Asia appears to be a hotspot of Paragyromitra biodiveristy with five out of eight species occrring there.
Pseudorhizina (3 species) Pseudorhizina produces funky, beautiful mushrooms with a lumpy cap and a strongly ribbed stem that sometimes displays dazzling pink to purple hues. The principal way to differentiate these species is with microscopy. Pseudorhizina californica and the related Pseudorhizina sp. 'PNW01' have ellipsoid spores, whereas Pseudorhizina sphaerospora has globose spores.
Pseudoverpa (1 species) A monotypic genus, Pseudoverpa contains the single species Pseudoverpa anthracobia. This is a rarely recorded genus with only a few samples from around the world.
ReferencesBahram M, Põlme S, Kõljalg U, Zarre S, Tedersoo L. 2012. Regional and local patterns of ectomycorrhizal fungal diversity and community structure along an altitudinal gradient in the Hyrcanian forests of northern Iran. New Phytologist 193: 465–473.
Calonge FD, Mata M, Umaña L. 2006. Adiciones y correcciones al catálogo de Ascomycota (Fungi) de Costa Rica, con especial referencia al género Scutellinia. Boletín de la Sociedad Micológica de Madrid 30: 25–34. Cho S-E, Kwag Y-N, Han S-K, Kim CS. 2021. Taxonomic re-evaluation of Korean Gyromitra species based on morphological and phylogenetical studies. The Korean Journal of Mycology 49: 363–371. Crous PW, Wingfield MJ, Burgess TI, Hardy GESJ, Gené J, Guarro J, Baseia IG, García D, Gusmão LFP, Souza-Motta CM, et al. 2018. Fungal Planet description sheets: 716-784. Persoonia 40: 240–393. Dirks AC, Mohamed OG, Schultz PJ, Miller AN, Tripathi A, James TY. 2023. Not all bad: gyromitrin has a limited distribution in the false morels as determined by a new ultra high-performance liquid chromatography method. Mycologia 115: 1–15. Dirks AC, Beug MW, Methven AS, Miller AN, James TY. 2024. Gyromitra persicula sp. nov. (Discinaceae, Pezizales), a novel discoid Gyromitra from Northwestern North America. Phytotaxa 644: 49–55. Dirks AC, Methven AS, Miller AN, Orozco-Quime M, Maurice S, Bonito G, Van Wyk J, Ahrendt S, Kuo A, Andreopoulos W, et al. 2025. Phylogenomic insights into the taxonomy, ecology, and mating systems of the lorchel family Discinaceae (Pezizales, Ascomycota). Molecular Phylogenetics and Evolution 205: 108286. Ekanayaka AH, Hyde KD, Jones EBG, Zhao Q. 2018. Taxonomy and phylogeny of operculate discomycetes: Pezizomycetes. Fungal Diversity 90: 161–243. Gilkey HM. 1947. New or otherwise noteworthy species of Tuberales. Mycologia 39: 441–452. Gómez Pignataro LD. 1972. Gyromitra chirripoensis nov. sp. Revista de biología tropical 20: 131–135. Gungor MY, Gongor H, Turkekul I. 2025. Reinforcing the generic status of Discina: morphological and phylogenetic evidence with new records from Türkiye. Phytotaxa 732:203–211. Harmaja H. 1986. Studies on the Pezizales. Karstenia 26: 41–48. Li L, Zhao Y-C, Zhang X-L, Su H-Y, Li S-H, Zhou D-Q. 2013. Hydnotrya laojunshanensis sp. nov. from China. Mycotaxon 125: 277–282. Li H-J, Chen Z-H, Cai Q, Zhou M-H, Chen G-J, Sun C-Y, Zhang H-S, Yang Z-L. 2020. Gyromitra venenata, a new poisonous species discovered from China. Mycosystema 39: 1706–1718. Li L, Wan S-P, Wang Y, Thongklang N, Tang S-M, Luo Z-L, Li S-H. 2023. New species of Hydnotrya (Ascomycota, Pezizomycetes) from southwestern China with notes on morphological characteristics of 17 species of Hydnotrya. MycoKeys 100: 49–67. Miller AN, Yoon A, Gulden G, Stensholt Ø, Van Vooren N, Ohenoja E, Methven AS. 2020. Studies in Gyromitra I: the Gyromitra gigas species complex. Mycological Progress 19: 1459–1473. Miller AN, Dirks AC, Filippova N, Popov E, Methven AS. 2022. Studies in Gyromitra II: cryptic speciation in the Gyromitra gigas species complex; rediscovery of G. ussuriensis and G. americanigigas sp. nov. Mycological Progress 21: 81. Miller AN, Dirks AC, Van Vooren N, Methven AS. 2025. Studies in Gyromitra III: the Gyromitra brunnea lineage including G. japonica sp. nov. Mycological Progress 24: 9. Van Vooren N. 2009. Essai taxinomique sur le genre Gyromitra Fr. sensu lato (Pezizales). 1. Introduction et systématique. Ascomycete.org 1: 3–6. Vooren NV. 2009. Essai taxinomique sur le genre Gyromitra Fr. sensu lato (Pezizales). 2. Le genre Gyromitra Fr., sous-genre Gyromitra. Ascomycete.org 1: 7–14. Van Vooren N. 2017. Typification of Gyromitra perlata, type-species of the subgenus Discina (Discinaceae). Ascomycete.org 9: 19–22. Van Vooren N, Hentic M. 2025. Discina spinosospora (Discinaceae), nouvelle espèce pour la fonge de France. Ascomycete.org 17: 43–46. Van Vooren N, Mauruc M-J. 2020. Révision des types de Pézizomycètes publiés par J.-C. Donadini (descriptions, illustrations, phylogénie). Van Vooren N, Moreau P-A. 2009. Essai taxinomique sur le genre Gyromitra Fr. sensu lato (Pezizales). 3. Le genre Gyromitra Fr., sous-genre Discina. Ascomycete.org 1: 3–13. Van Vooren N, Moreau P-A. 2009. Essai taxinomique sur le genre Gyromitra Fr. sensu lato (Pezizales). 7. Taxons exclus, douteux ou insuffisamment connus. Ascomycete.org 1: 3–10. Vassilkov BP. 1969. O gribakh (makromitsetakh) sovetskoy arktiki [Ascomycetous fungi (macromycetes) of the Soviet Arctic]. Mikologiya i Fitopatologiya 3: 114–120. Wang X-C, Zhuang W-Y. 2019. A three-locus phylogeny of Gyromitra (Discinaceae, Pezizales) and discovery of two cryptic species. Mycologia 111: 69–77. Wang X-C, Yang Z-L, Chen S-L, Bau T, Li T-H, Li L, Fan L, Zhuang W-Y. 2023. Phylogeny and taxonomic revision of the family Discinaceae (Pezizales, Ascomycota). Microbiology Spectrum 11: e00207-23. Xu Y-Y, Wang Y-W, Li T, Yan X-Y, Fan L. 2018. DNA analysis reveals rich diversity of Hydnotrya with emphasis on the species found in China. Mycological Progress 17: 1123–1137. Xu A, Lu J-J, Lin W-F, Fan L, Xie M-L, Wan S-P, Li Y. 2023. Hydnotrya qinghaiensis sp. nov. (Discinaceae, Pezizales) from Tibetan Plateau, China. Phytotaxa 616: 235–246.
0 Comments
Your comment will be posted after it is approved.
Leave a Reply. |
PermalinksProject Introduction Top EdiblesHericium coralloides
Laetiporus sulphureus Morchella americana Polyporus umbellatus Tricholoma magnivelare Archives
June 2026
Categories
All
|
|
Terms of Use, Liability Waiver, and Licensing
The material on aldendirks.com is presented for general informational and educational purposes only and under no circumstances is to be considered a substitute for identification of an actual biological specimen by a person qualified to make that judgment. CC BY-NC-ND 4.0 |